The jesting didn't end there. One player even taped a glove to the back of Joyce's jersey.
Teammate Kelly Johnson campaigned to have Joyce's play merit more exposure on blooper reels.
"I've been on the '[ESPN] Not Top 10' plenty of times," Johnson said, "so speaking as someone who has had to laugh at himself, I think that definitely needs to make its way on there."
Johnson did, however, sympathize with his fellow outfielder.
"He's trying to be aggressive and make a play," Johnson said. "It's hard sometimes to shut that off and take a step back and imagine if you have a really legitimate chance to catch it. You always think you have a chance to catch it. It's part of being competitive."
Zack Meisel is a reporter for MLB.com. Follow him on Twitter @zackmeisel. This story was not subject to the approval of Major League Baseball or its clubs.