"They're kind of two different players," Maddon said. "At the same age, Desmond [is] probably more advanced as a baseball player, Carl [was] more of a slashing kind of a guy, with power. Carl's got power, more a slashing kind of hitter. Desmond is more willing to stand back there and take a different kind of swing. Speed-wise, I don't know who would win a race. That'd be a pretty good race right there. Defensively, [they're] pretty close."